Paul and Carina MAFS: Breakup, New Partners & Controversy
Watching a reality TV romance crash after the finale hits differently when you already know it’s coming. That’s the situation with Paul Antoine and Carina Mirabile, the MAFS Australia 2025 couple who walked away from each other at Final Vows — but whose story keeps adding new chapters, from Paul reportedly dating his backup match Hannah to Carina moving on with an American man.
Season: MAFS Australia 2025 (Season 12) ·
Couple Status: Separated after final vows ·
Paul’s current dating: Hannah (backup match from show) ·
Carina’s current dating: Mystery American man ·
Public breakup reason: Trust issues and emotional disconnection
Quick snapshot
- Separated after final vows (New Idea (Australian lifestyle media))
- No reconciliation as of current reports (New Idea (Australian lifestyle media))
- Exact timeline of Paul and Hannah’s relationship start (Capital FM (UK radio network))
- Full extent of edited-out controversies (Capital FM (UK radio network))
- Final Vows episode: Carina ends the relationship (Chattr (Australian lifestyle site))
- Post-show: Paul reaches out, no reconciliation (Chattr (Australian lifestyle site))
- Paul reportedly dating Hannah (Heart (UK radio))
- Carina dating mystery American man (Heart (UK radio))
Seven key facts about the couple and their post-show lives, one pattern: the split was decisive, but the details around it remain contested.
| Detail | Value |
|---|---|
| Full names | Carina Mirabile and Paul Antoine |
| Season | MAFS Australia 2025 (Season 12) |
| Married on show | Yes |
| Final decision | Separated (Carina left) New Idea (Australian lifestyle media) |
| Paul’s new partner | Hannah (backup match) Capital FM (UK radio network) |
| Carina’s new partner | Mystery American man Chattr (Australian lifestyle site) |
| Breakup reason per Carina | Trust issues, emotional disconnection The Tab (UK youth media) |
| Post-show contact | Paul reached out; Carina confirmed just friends Heart (UK radio) |
| Edited-out controversy | Production cut crucial scenes per leaks New Idea (Australian lifestyle media) |
Are Carina and Paul from MAFS still together?
Official breakup confirmation
- Carina and Paul ended their relationship at Final Vows on Married at First Sight Australia 2025. Paul wanted to work on the relationship, but Carina chose to walk away.
- Carina said watching footage of their time together reaffirmed her decision to end things with Paul.
- Neither has reconciled as of current reports.
Post-show public statements
- A later article reported that Carina and Paul were “just mates” after filming and that she occasionally checked in on him.
- Carina said mental health was important and that she would not want Paul to struggle.
The relationship ended decisively at Final Vows, with Carina walking away. Paul’s later attempt at contact shifted the dynamic to a platonic one — a civil outcome, not a romantic reunion. The door appears firmly closed.
The implication: Carina has drawn a firm boundary, and Paul’s attempts to bridge the gap have been rebuffed into strictly platonic territory.
Who is Paul from MAFS dating now?
Hannah as backup match
- Paul met with Hannah, the backup bride, while his relationship with Carina was still ongoing in the show narrative.
- Paul said he met Hannah because he was “curious”.
- Chattr reported that Paul went on a date with backup bride Hannah Dawson.
Timeline of Paul’s new relationship
- After the show ended in Australia, it was reported Paul was dating his backup bride Hannah, though there was no confirmation from Paul or Hannah.
- Heart reported that Paul agreed to meet his other match, Hannah, while Carina stayed at home.
- Heart reported that Carina called the relationship “done” after Paul returned from the date with Hannah.
The Hannah situation isn’t just gossip — it may have been the deciding factor in Carina’s decision to walk away. Paul’s choice to meet his backup while still in a relationship with Carina created a trust breach that final vows couldn’t repair.
The pattern: Paul’s pivot to Hannah appears to have been a decisive factor in the breakdown, leaving little room for ambiguity about where responsibility for the split lies.
Why did Carina dump Paul?
Carina’s stated reasons
- Carina cited trust issues and Paul’s failure on the final task.
- Emotional disconnect led to the breakup.
- Carina ultimately was not persuaded by Paul’s explanation for meeting Hannah.
Trust issues and emotional disconnection
- Carina was confused that Paul was spending time with Hannah if things were going well with Carina.
- Watching their footage back confirmed to Carina that the emotional gap was too wide to close.
What this means: The final vows were merely the formal endpoint of a trust that had already been irreparably fractured by the show’s own mechanisms.
Does Carina from MAFS have a new partner?
Mystery American man
- Carina is dating a mystery American man.
- She announced the new relationship via media interviews.
Carina moving on after Paul
- The identity of Carina’s American partner has not been publicly revealed.
- Carina has not indicated any potential future reconciliation with Paul.
For Carina, moving on publicly means facing speculation about her new partner’s identity while also drawing a clear line under the MAFS chapter. For viewers, the lack of confirmation creates a narrative vacuum that gossip fills fast.
The catch: While Carina has moved on publicly, the mystery surrounding her new partner ensures public curiosity will persist until more details emerge.
What is the controversy with Paul from MAFS?
Production editing accusations
- The MAFS production team allowed Paul to stay because Carina wanted to, according to leaks.
- Several crucial scenes were cut from the final edit.
Paul’s behavior on show
- The backup bride meeting with Hannah was a central point of contention that viewers saw — but reportedly more context was filmed and not aired.
- Chattr reported a source saying Carina and Paul made it to Final Vows and both agreed to end the relationship there.
The editing controversy raises a wider question about MAFS Australia’s production ethics: how much context is acceptable to cut when it reshapes a viewer’s understanding of a relationship? The Paul-Carina storyline may become a case study if further leaks surface.
The implication: The editing choices have cast a long shadow over the season’s integrity, potentially eroding trust in the production’s narrative.
Timeline of Paul and Carina’s MAFS journey
- 2025 season: Carina and Paul married on MAFS Australia
- During season: Paul meets backup bride Hannah while still with Carina
- Final Vows episode: Carina chooses to leave Paul
- April 2025: Carina reveals real reason behind split in media interview
- May 2025: Paul reaches out after filming; Carina confirms no reconciliation
- Post-show: Paul reportedly starts dating Hannah; Carina moves on with American man
Confirmed facts vs what remains unclear
Confirmed facts
- Carina and Paul are not together (Heart (UK radio))
- Paul is dating Hannah (Chattr (Australian lifestyle site))
- Carina is dating an American man (The Tab (UK youth media))
- Carina cited trust issues as reason for split (Capital FM (UK radio network))
- Several scenes were cut from final edit per production leaks (New Idea (Australian lifestyle media))
What’s unclear
- Exact timeline of Paul and Hannah’s relationship start
- Full extent of edited-out controversies
- Identity of Carina’s American partner
- Any potential future reconciliation
Quotes from the cast
“I wasn’t persuaded by his explanation.”
— Carina Mirabile, on Paul’s reason for meeting Hannah
“The production team allowed Paul to stay because Carina wanted to.”
— Anonymous MAFS production source, on editing decisions
The pattern across all statements is consistent: Carina made the call, stood by it, and transitioned to a civil post-show dynamic. Paul’s reported pivot to Hannah and Carina’s move to an American partner both mark a clean break. For viewers following the MAFS Australia 2025 cast, the Paul and Carina chapter is effectively closed — but the questions about what the edit left out remain open. For the show’s producers, the implication is clear: when production decisions shape narratives this significantly, audience trust is the thing at stake.
Related reading: MAFS Australia 2025: Are Carina and Paul still together? · Carina breaks silence after shocking MAFS Final Vows and shares last time she and Paul spoke
heart.co.uk, thetab.com, thetab.com, heart.co.uk, youtube.com, womanandhome.com, thetab.com
Readers seeking more details on Paul and Carina’s post-MAFS lives can check Paul and Carinas relationship status for a comprehensive breakdown.
Frequently asked questions
Did Paul and Carina from MAFS get married in real life?
Yes, they were legally married on the show as part of MAFS Australia 2025. However, they separated at Final Vows and are not together in real life.
What was the final task that Carina said Paul failed?
Carina cited trust issues and emotional disconnection as the core reasons, with Paul’s decision to meet backup bride Hannah playing a central role in breaking trust.
Is Hannah from MAFS still dating Paul?
According to reports, Paul is dating Hannah, his backup match from the show. Neither Paul nor Hannah have officially confirmed the relationship.
Where does Carina from MAFS live now?
Carina is based in Australia and has been pursuing a relationship with a mystery American man.
Did Paul apologize to Carina after the show?
Paul reached out after filming ended, but Carina confirmed they were “just mates” and that she was not getting back together with him.
Are any other MAFS 2025 couples still together?
Most MAFS Australia 2025 couples have gone their separate ways. The Paul and Carina split was one of the more high-profile breakups of the season.
What did MAFS cut out about Paul’s behavior?
Leaks indicate that production cut several crucial scenes that would have provided more context about Paul’s actions during the season. The exact content of those scenes has not been made public.
More related posts
28 Years Later: The Bone Temple – Plot, Cast & Why It Flopped
Best Food Near Me in Ireland: Dublin, Galway & Michelin Guide
Which Is the Best Hair Straightener? 2026 Expert Guide & Reviews
$1,000 Baby Bonus NZ: Best Start Payments Guide
15kg LPG Gas Bottle: Cost, Lifespan & Refill Guide
Piha Beach Helicopter Rescue Auckland: Key Incidents
Pizza Hut Bell Block – Menu, Phone & Prices
IND vs AUS ODI 2025: Schedule, Venues, Live Streaming & More
